turn blog comments back on

If you’ve turned your blog comments off here’s why you should turn them back on!

Back in March 2014 CopyBlogger turned their blog comments off. And Michael Hyatt did the same thing in January 2015.

But guess what? In January 2016 they turned their blog comments back on again!

They claim they did this as an experiment to see what would happen. And even if it was, I am overjoyed that they decided blog comments are worth having and have activated them again.

Because for me a blog without comments totally defeats the objective of having a blog in the first place. Even Michael Hyatt said “Running a blog without comments is like hosting a party without a venue.”

Here’s one of my Infographics to show you visually what I mean:

Why you should turn your blog comments back on

And here’s some code you could paste into your own posts (via the text mode) if you want to share this Infographic with your readers.

I hate it when there’s no comment box

I come across a fabulous post that really fired me up and I want to leave a comment. But when I pan down to the bottom of the page to find the comment box, there isn’t one.

Disbelief turns to despair as I realise that if I’m going to leave a comment, I have to leave this blog and go find the author on social media.

It’s another process to do. Something else that makes my desire to comment begin to evaporate. The hassle of searching for the most appropriate networking platform (which one? Twitter? Facebook? Google+?) is further aggravated by the fact that I don’t really want to leave a comment on social media.

I don’t want the world and his wife to read what I have to say there. I want to say it in the confines of this blog. Next to the post which inspired me to comment in the first place. Not somewhere else less personal and irrelevant to the present situation.

I haven’t introduced myself to the blog’s author on social media. It seems intrusive that my first conversation with them should be about a post that isn’t immediately available on that platform. Totally inappropriate.

What do other readers think about this post?

Having no comments at the bottom of a post doesn’t tell me much about the kind of readership the blog gets. Neither does it let me know anything about the blog’s popularity, whether the writer is any good or not, whether it’s worth my while bothering to stay and read any more.

Not having any visible feedback may be uninviting for me, but it must be extremely demoralising for the writer. How do they know if their post is successful? OK, they may be happy to scrutinise their traffic stats, but that doesn’t say everything.

If you want to encourage more readers to come to your blog and read your stuff, you have to make them feel welcome. Turn your blog comments back on to build a sense of community. Make your readers believe you write your blog specially for them.

You’re not going to achieve this effectively if your readers are not able to express themselves, show their gratitude and appreciation to what you have written, by having the opportunity to leave a comment.

Commenting creates a community, which is the blog’s heart, its raison d’etre. Your blog is nothing without its readers, so why do you deny them the pleasure of letting you know what they think?

How do potential readers know your blog’s worth?

Social proof is a powerful marketing tool. By turning your blog comments back on means you’ll start to get lots of comments again. This give the impression your blog is popular, especially since the majority of visitors will know that not all of your readers will have left a comment.

Popularity is always a crowd-puller. People always want to know what’s going on, and a large gathering of comments gives the impression that your content is worth reading. Also they will all want to join the party and be where the fun is happening.

Therefore you need to continue having a conversation with your readers outside the post. But not necessarily outside of the blog. Keep your readers inside, safe and warm, where there’s more content available that also might interest them.

And don’t forget to reply to your reader’s comments. This is much easier if you can do this on the blog. It all happens in one place, next to the blog post in question, and you can respond appropriately to each comment in self-contained and relevant threads.

Whereas on social media, you may have to keep flitting from one platform to another, trying to keep up with the comments when they occur. And since social media commenting is not restricted by spam filters and moderation, you can’t regulate what gets published. Threads can easily wander away from the subject, and contributions tend to be less full and meaningful.

Big blogs didn’t do better without comments

This is most interesting. Apparently the amount of traffic to the likes of CopyBlogger and Michael Hyatt’s blog flatlined during the time comments were turned off. It seems that not being able to leave a comment was not conducive to a passing readership.

One of the main reasons for turning blog comments off was because of spam. Especially when you get hundreds or thousands of comments a day, working out which ones were legitimate was getting more difficult. Apparently human spammers were getting increasingly clever at writing comments that looked real.

However, it was noted that most spammers targeted old posts. They weren’t interested in the most recent content provided for readers. What they wanted was traffic to increase their back-links back to their websites.

So the answer was to turn blog comments back on again and reduce the amount of time readers could contribute. This successfully kept the spammers at bay. And the real readers who wanted to show their appreciation, challenge the subject or offer their opinion were able to do so within a smaller time-frame soon after the post was published.

As soon as comment boxes were opened again, the readers returned. And this in turn encouraged the bloggers to write more posts. Not only that, the feedback they received showed them what the readers wanted to read, so they were able to provide much more meaningful and appropriate content for their readers.

Now it’s over to you

Did you succumb to the trend and turn your comments off? Were you ever comfortable about doing that, or was it a relief not to have the bother of moderating them? This will depend on how many comments you were lucky enough to receive in the first place.

But now that the likes of CopyBlogger have turned their blog comments back on again, will you be encouraged to follow suit?

Let me know if you have, or if you have no intentions of ever allowing comments ever again. Because if it’s the latter, then I feel sorry for your readers.

Blogs were designed to include comments. Don’t take that facility away. Turn your comments back on again!

And please leave me some comments too, to make me happy and to show I also have some readers who care.

Alice Dec 2023 paper background
Alice Elliott

Alice Elliott (aka the award winning Fairy Blog Mother) has been helping bloggers understand about blogging for two decades.

She has also been scrutinising the benefits of commenting on blogs and social media for both individuals and businesses for a decade.

She offers web design with empathetic encouragement and understanding.

Check out these other fabulous posts:

how to connect with your blog readers

8 tips on how to connect with your blog readers

I’m pleased when I see questions on Quora asking how to connect with readers on a blog. These, of course, come

barrier to commenting on blogs

Example of a barrier to commenting on blogs

I mentioned in my last post how important it was to comment on other blogs. Especially if you wanted to

how commenting can transform your blog's performance

How commenting can transform your blog’s performance

Would you like a quick-fix action to transform your blog’s performance? Normally when someone offers that kind of suggestion, any

commenting helps with SEO

How commenting helps with SEO for your blog

Sometimes we need to be motivated to comment on blogs. So if I told you blog commenting helps with SEO,

facebook comments

Why Facebook comments now favour active content

A lot of people are moaning about the recent changes in Facebook comments. Whereas I see this as excellent news!

how to make answering comments more satisfying

How to make answering comments more satisfying

We all love receiving comments. It gives us a glow to know that at least someone has read your posts


Let me know what you think of this post

  • I love commenting on posts. I even created a WordPress account just so I could comment on WordPress blogs. I have a blog on Blogger, and I’m currently umming and ahing over whether to migrate elsewhere. The Blogger comments system was quite poor, so I change to Disqus, which I much prefer, and it’s far easier for people to comment. I know it’s easier because my mum can finally do it! However, I get very few comments. It’s disheartening. Thanks for this post – I hope more people make commenting on their posts easier now 🙂

    • Thank you Laura for your comment. The subject of how easy it is to comment on a blog is suitable for another post (watch this space!), but it is important if this process is made more accessible so the reader’s enthusiasm is not hindered in any way. As for not getting enough comments, I know it is disheartening. A little tip is to comment more yourself, to attract attention to you and your blog, and then hopefully the other bloggers will return and do the same on your blog.

  • Wow! I made it to the bottom of the post and comments ? This is my first comment, and I read the post through, though it took two days. Lots of links to check out.

    So much to learn. Thank you for being open and personable and teaching us how it is to be done! I\’m hoping my comment posts, as I\’m one of those WordPress people.

    Ashley Jones

    • Thanks for commenting Ashley! And welcome to the world of commenting. Now you’ve done your first one, I suggest you search for more blogs in your niche and start commenting on there. Make sure you only write stuff that is relevant to the post, it is well written and helpful to anyone, blogger or reader, who comes across it later.

  • Very interesting! A listener to our podcast recommended this post after I mentioned comments on a recent show.

    The biggest gripe for me has to be spam. I just felt that for a B2B blog, there was more valuable discussion on social media and less spam.

    But you’ve got me thinking again…

    • Thank you for commenting Jon. And I’m glad I’ve got you thinking again about blog commenting. Spam is a major nuisance, and certainly drives a lot of bloggers into closing down their comment sections. But with suitable moderation systems in place, and a drive to build up a following of commenters who contribute something worthwhile to publish, there is no reason why commenting on blogs can start to thrive once more.

  • Great! Thank you for sharing great directories list with pr. I was searching quality directory site to submit me new blogging site. I also followed the video link that makes me clear about Directories Submission.

  • {"email":"Email address invalid","url":"Website address invalid","required":"Required field missing"}